Secondaries

An Offer You Can't Refuse: Why You Should be a Secondary Seller

December 13, 2019
  • SHARE

In the 1972 film classic, The Godfather, Marlon Brando’s title character is asked how he will make a stubborn man see things his way. His response, “I’ll make him an offer he can’t refuse,” is emblematic of the way he approaches issues. By turning potential problems into win-win solutions, both parties can benefit.

The same might be said about the private equity secondary market. Once a niche sector of the private markets landscape, secondaries have officially gone mainstream over the last few years. Media coverage abounds, whether about the latest transaction or exploring some emerging trend within the market. 

While there are benefits to participating in a growing and evolving market, the level of complexity and specialization has increased, posing a challenge to limited partners looking to ramp up their exposure or allocate to secondaries for the first time. It is against this backdrop that we offer some considerations that can help LPs navigate the secondary market and expand, evolve or reshape their private market portfolios. 

It may seem like a distant memory, but it was not long ago that the majority of secondary market sales were executed out of necessity – when liquidity was tight, capital calls were looming and the broader market was in distress. It is quite a different picture today, with the selling of fund stakes now an integral component of prudent portfolio management.

The best way to visualize this change is to look at the increase in deal flow volume in the secondary market over the past five years and contrast that with the current financial backdrop, where markets are rising and institutional investors are struggling to put money to work. No longer are distressed or forced divestitures the predominant catalyst for a transaction. Instead, LPs increasingly are viewing secondary market sales as a way to reshape their portfolios for a wide variety of reasons, which may include: 

  • Funds that are non-core to their private equity strategy 
  • Rationalizing number of GP relationships 
  • Performance, access or succession issues 
  • Strategy drift within the general partner community 
  • At target allocation and redeploying into core managers 
  • Significant remaining net asset value, but low level of distributions 
  • Over-exposure to a single company or industry 
  • Reverse denominator effect
“No longer are distressed or forced divestiture the predominant catalyst for a transaction. Instead, LPs increasingly are viewing secondary market sales as a way to reshape their portfolios...

See what we mean? These examples demonstrate that there are a number of motivations driving potential divestitures, as well as multiple ways to cross the finish line. None of these examples are considered unique in today’s market, whereas most would have been at the turn of the decade. 

Changes in leadership also can precipitate a decision to sell down holdings. We have observed instances of new CIOs who decide to take the portfolio in a new direction, and thus look to offload fund stakes. Newer board members may also demonstrate a tendency to approve or reject fund sales differently than their predecessors. 

We have seen one notable example of portfolio rebalancing in the current state of affairs of a domestic LP. The new CIO concluded that the plan held too many GP relationships, and is now attempting to create a much more concentrated portfolio with deeper relationships. As a rebalancing was being contemplated, one of the main points of consideration pertained to opportunity cost and cost of capital. If the money currently tied up in certain funds could be redeployed elsewhere, earning a higher return, then it would make sense to sell. Ultimately, the LP concluded that its pipeline of future investment opportunities outweighed the return potential of a portion of its current holdings, and it sold a mix of funds at various price points. In doing so, the seller was able to utilize this capital in ways it believed would better position its portfolio for future growth. 

This is only one example, and a prominent one at that. And yet, we believe it is reflective of the manner in which other investors are approaching the secondary market today. We don’t expect to see a reversal in terms of overall secondary volume anytime soon. Some of that belief stems from observations that LPs who have conducted a successful sale are more likely to pursue additional sales in the future. Another element has to do with the fact that, in any given year, 1.5-2% of all private capital raised changes hands in the secondary market. As fundraising booms in the private markets, this will provide a natural tailwind to volume, as seen in the chart below. Additionally, some of the largest vehicles raised recently have been dedicated secondary funds providing an increasing amount of dry powder.

When does this part of the market hit its peak? We’re not sure that it will. Yes, private fund commitments are “illiquid.” Yes, most have a ten-year capital lockup. But do they really? With the ability to sell holdings becoming easier every year, there is no need for investors to perpetually retain vehicles managed by non-core sponsors. 

As we move into the next decade, the secondary market is well-positioned to expand in terms of type, scope and size as the market matures. Growth also will be driven by institutional investors that have made their maiden allocations to the private markets or that are expecting to do so in the near term. Naturally, a broader base of limited partners eventually leads to a deeper pool of sellers. And, if we may be so bold as to end this piece looking into the future, we think annual trading volume could potentially reach $200 billion in the next decade based on the past several years of growth. Marlon Brando would be proud.


DEFINITIONS

All Private Markets:
Hamilton Lane’s definition of “All Private Markets” includes all private commingled funds excluding fund-of-funds, and secondary fund-of-funds.
MSCI World Index:
The MSCI World Index tracks large and mid-cap equity performance in developed market countries.



This presentation has been prepared solely for informational purposes and contains confidential and proprietary information, the disclosure of which could be harmful to Hamilton Lane. Accordingly, the recipients of this presentation are requested to maintain the confidentiality of the information contained herein. This presentation may not be copied or distributed, in whole or in part, without the prior written consent of Hamilton Lane. 

The information contained in this presentation may include forward-looking statements regarding returns, performance, opinions, the fund presented or its portfolio companies, or other events contained herein. Forward-looking statements include a number of risks, uncertainties and other factors beyond our control, or the control of the fund or the portfolio companies, which may result in material differences in actual results, performance or other expectations. The opinions, estimates and analyses reflect our current judgment, which may change in the future. 

All opinions, estimates and forecasts of future performance or other events contained herein are based on information available to Hamilton Lane as of the date of this presentation and are subject to change. Past performance of the investments described herein is not indicative of future results. In addition, nothing contained herein shall be deemed to be a prediction of future performance. The information included in this presentation has not been reviewed or audited by independent public accountants. Certain information included herein has been obtained from sources that Hamilton Lane believes to be reliable, but the accuracy of such information cannot be guaranteed. 

This presentation is not an offer to sell, or a solicitation of any offer to buy, any security or to enter into any agreement with Hamilton Lane or any of its affiliates. Any such offering will be made only at your request. We do not intend that any public offering will be made by us at any time with respect to any potential transaction discussed in this presentation. Any offering or potential transaction will be made pursuant to separate documentation negotiated between us, which will supersede entirely the information contained herein. 

Certain of the performance results included herein do not reflect the deduction of any applicable advisory or management fees, since it is not possible to allocate such fees accurately in a vintage year presentation or in a composite measured at different points in time. A client’s rate of return will be reduced by any applicable advisory or management fees, carried interest and any expenses incurred. Hamilton Lane’s fees are described in Part 2 of our Form ADV, a copy of which is available upon request. 

The following hypothetical example illustrates the effect of fees on earned returns for both separate accounts and fund-of-funds investment vehicles. The example is solely for illustration purposes and is not intended as a guarantee or prediction of the actual returns that would be earned by similar investment vehicles having comparable features. The example is as follows: The hypothetical separate account or fund-of-funds consisted of $100 million in commitments with a fee structure of 1.0% on committed capital during the first four years of the term of the investment and then declining by 10% per year thereafter for the 12-year life of the account. The commitments were made during the first three years in relatively equal increments and the assumption of returns was based on cash flow assumptions derived from a historical database of actual private equity cash flows. Hamilton Lane modeled the impact of fees on four different return streams over a 12- year time period. In these examples, the effect of the fees reduced returns by approximately 2%. This does not include performance fees, since the performance of the account would determine the effect such fees would have on returns. Expenses also vary based on the particular investment vehicle and, therefore, were not included in this hypothetical example. Both performance fees and expenses would further decrease the return. 

Hamilton Lane (UK) Limited is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Hamilton Lane Advisors, L.L.C. Hamilton Lane (UK) Limited is authorized and regulated by the Financial Conducts Authority. In the UK this communication is directed solely at persons who would be classified as a professional client or eligible counterparty under the FCA Handbook of Rules and Guidance. Its contents are not directed at, may not be suitable for and should not be relied upon by retail clients. 

Hamilton Lane Advisors, L.L.C. is exempt from the requirement to hold an Australian financial services licence under the Corporations Act 2001 in respect of the financial services by operation of ASIC Class Order 03/1100: U.S. SEC regulated financial service providers. Hamilton Lane Advisors, L.L.C. is regulated by the SEC under U.S. laws, which differ from Australian laws. 

Any tables, graphs or charts relating to past performance included in this presentation are intended only to illustrate the performance of the indices, composites, specific accounts or funds referred to for the historical periods shown. Such tables, graphs and charts are not intended to predict future performance and should not be used as the basis for an investment decision. 

The information herein is not intended to provide, and should not be relied upon for, accounting, legal or tax advice, or investment recommendations. You should consult your accounting, legal, tax or other advisors about the matters discussed herein. 

The calculations contained in this document are made by Hamilton Lane based on information provided by the general partner (e.g. cash flows and valuations), and have not been prepared, reviewed or approved by the general partners. 

As of December 13, 2019

Recent Content

news

Hamilton Lane Closes its Largest Fund To-Date, Collecting $3.9 Billion for its Fifth Secondaries Vehicle

Firm’s largest fund receives strong demand from globally-diverse LP base, well exceeding its target

Read the Press Release
news

Legend Capital announces successful closing of continuation fund

Legend Capital announces successful closing of continuation fund

Read the Press Release
insight

Secondary Return Attribution

These days, it seems like secondaries appear to be attractive because of their discounts. But, success in secondaries depends on more than just love at first sight.

Read the Blog Post

FPO We use cookies to improve user experience, and analyze web traffic. For those reasons, we may share your site usage with our analytics partners.

Learn More